by Gerry Rising
There are many fine books about the out of doors – authors like Ernest Thompson Seton, John Burroughs, Henry David Thoreau and John McPhee come immediately to mind – but the first thing most of us are interested in about nature is identification. What are those birds at my feeders? What are those roadside wildflowers? What tree is producing that floating cotton? What is that butterfly visiting my garden?
Those identification questions are seemingly endless. There are, after all, hundreds of birds and mammals, thousands of wildflowers and tens of thousands of insects.
And each time you come across another animal or plant in the wild, you probably wonder not only about its identification but also whether it is common or rare and whether it is native to the area or an alien. Those are things you also find in identification guides.
There are literally hundreds of such guides and new ones are published almost weekly. In just the past month I have received three. You and I can easily find ourselves overwhelmed. So let me try to sort out this long list to give you a few key books you should consider as starters.
If I had to pick just one identification guide, it would be the Reader’s Digest North American Wildlife. I salute the dozens of authors and artists who contributed to this book. This compendium includes mammals, birds, reptiles and amphibians, fish, invertebrates, trees and shrubs, wildflowers, nonflowering plants, and mushrooms. Tiny range maps accompany each species to give a general idea of where it is to be found.
This is the one guide I carry on canoe trips when weight is a serious concern. And it has served me well. Obviously, selections have been made to keep the total species illustrated to 2000, but rarely have I come across one not included in this excellent book.
What is too often lost on beginners is the idea of communities. As a city forester once told me, “Every tree has its particular insect parasites.” Some animals even take their name from an association: the spicebush swallowtail butterfly, for example, is often found near spicebushes. And this is true in general. You find particular mammals, birds, insects and plants occur in certain types of community. And that can help a great deal with identification.
A good book about such communities is John Kricher’s Eastern Forests. (Like many of the other books I will be mentioning, it is one of the Roger Tory Peterson field guide series.) If you are planning a visit to south Florida, for example, you would be well advised to read the section about the Everglades in Kricher’s book. Stephen Whitney has written a similar guide to Western Forests.
But there is another way of thinking about communities. Start with a single species, say a sugar maple, and consider all the insects and plants you would expect to find nearby. Or, in fact, expect not to find: goldenrods and sugar maples don’t mix (in technical jargon, they are allelopathic).
A delightful series of books by John Eastman address communities in this way. Among them are The Book of Forest and Thicket, The Book of Swamp and Bog and The Book of Field and Roadside. I promise you that you will see nature in a new way when you delve into any one of these books.
Now to a few of the guides that focus on particular classes of wildlife.
There are many fine candidates for bird guides. The best remains the first. I have used successive editions of Roger Tory Peterson’s Field Guide to Birds of Eastern North America since shortly after the first was published (and immediately sold out) in 1934. New updated editions continue to be produced despite Peterson’s death in 1996. There is a corresponding western guide that I use when traveling. In 2010, the eastern and western guides were combined into a new Peterson Field Guide to Birds of North America, but the accompanying new editions of the eastern and western guides are smaller and easier to carry.
Many advanced birders prefer The Sibley Guide to Birds by David Allen Sibley, which devotes a single page to each species. I prefer the Peterson guides because they include group portraits of similar species for comparison. This is especially important for beginners.
For those of you whose focus is on bird feeding, a 2010 book by Bill Thompson III, will serve you well. Its title is Identifying and Feeding Birds. Bill is also editor of Bird Watcher’s Digest, an outstanding periodical for birders of all abilities.
There are two excellent wildflower books I carry in my car. Since I cannot choose between them, I will recommend both. Long a favorite has been the Peterson and McKenny Northeastern Wildflowers, but I began to use the key in Newcomb’s Wildflower Guide by Lawrence Newcomb a few years ago and find it very helpful in narrowing down identification. (There is a discipline to using a key but learning the procedure is well worth the effort. Taxonomists – scientists who identify and name organisms – use keys all the time.)
Eric Eaton, with Kenn Kaufman as co-author, has addressed a near-impossible task and produced the Kaufman Field Guide to Insects of North America. They have had to make choices to focus on the most common of the over 90,000 species found in this hemisphere, but they offer what a professional entomologist friend calls “an incomparable guide.”
Without the fanfare they deserve, I mention two other guides, both in the Peterson series: Mammals of North America and Eastern Reptiles and Amphibians; and an excellent book on trees: Grolier’s Field Guide to North American Trees by Thomas S. Elias.
*
Gerry Rising is a State University of New York Distinguished Teaching Professor Emeritus. He was editor of the New York State journal, The Kingbird, and continues to write a weekly “Nature Watch” column for The Buffalo Sunday News.